Sunday, September 16, 2012

Coal Sham

How can me! Such a gifted person be far behind in putting forward his views on coal gate. Now this statement might look like of a sycophant or act of self-indulgence but I call it self-motivation.
However, larger issue before nation and us is "Credibility" of people holding highest office of land. I did some thinking on these and tried to draw reason out of Congress argument but could not resonate much with them except the fact that every party is guilty. Let’s dissect each argument on facts and rational. I am not economist and tried to keep things simpler without compromising on logical reasoning.

1. Coal is still not excavated and hence no Loss - My argument bullshit and CRAP and I don't think we need to justify this.
2. Power will be cheaper: As per common sense point 1 and 2 cannot be true simultaneously so logically inconsistent. They should decide their line of defense as point 1 and point 2 contradicts. Also, there is no clause binding on private parties on price banding of end result be it cement, power or steel. Hence there is no correlation between selling of coal blocks and pricing of end result.
3. India needs power and hence we give 154 coal blocks for free: This is far from reality, not based on facts.If you were so serious about power generation you should have an efficient regulatory mechanism and ensured power is generated and should have published targets for private players. . Neither any of them has shown intent or look pressurized to generate power. 
4. NDA policy and we are following: That's weakest argument you can get. A government in power is hiding behind the govt. which was in power eight years before. Its neither religious practice nor binding for any government to follow its predecessors especially if they know it’s wrong.
5. It was transparent in dealing and nothing to hide: I believe Supreme Court asking them a well-articulated questions make govt exposed bare naked. The Question asked by Supreme Court is “How come only politicians were allotted by this fair and transparent system"
7. CAG is wrong in its calculation: Does it matter if they are off by few thousand crores as the scale is 1.84 lakh crores.Also, by asking this question you are putting more questions to your credibility
8. BJP is equally responsible for coal scam: Potentially true they may be but you are answerable.

Insult to Injury , Mr Sushil Shinde remark “People will forget this as they have forgotten “Bofors”. 
Hope we will not forget this plunder of country as this has been inflicted upon us by malign  intent of govt. Sorry Mr. Prime Minister, your personal integrity is no good and your silence is deafening and not appreciated. Your weakness has cost us dear and damages should be reversed.
I like many others hold you in high regards and disappointed like many others for betrayal 
I am more disappointed by the fact that how the whole system conglomerate and collaborate to cover up operation on wafer thin logic and absurdity as if billions of Indians are kids studying in Kinder garden.
Mr Shinde- "Vishwaas-ghat" bleeds deep and hurts most and this government is guilty of it. We need leaders in whom people can repose their faith. Whose integrity cannot be compromised and admit its failure with grace, put nation before self. You or anyone in congress are absolute contrary to good leadership paradigm so we, the people, as supreme power of nation fire you from your job.
I demand that we should constitutionally get right to hire and fire. Voting is half baked right where we can only hire govt and they suck our blood for five years.




1 comment: